ADU vs Guest House: In-depth Comparison and Key Differences

Last updated on December 10, 2023

Choosing between an accessory dwelling unit (ADU) and a guest house may seem daunting because each offers unique benefits and drawbacks that can impact your home’s sustainability and functionality.

As you explore the realm of sustainable housing, there’s no doubt you’ve encountered the terms ‘ADU‘ and ‘Guest House‘, and you may be wondering what makes each unique.

Accessory Dwelling Units, or ADUs, are self-sufficient units that have their own bedrooms, kitchen facilities, and bathrooms, whereas a guest house also offers separate living accommodations but generally within the same building envelope as the primary home; so, they share more amenities.

How do their functions, costs and regulations differ? Stick around for a comprehensive comparison to fully understand which option best accommodates your needs and preferences.

Key takeaways:

  • Guest houses are typically used for short-term stays, while ADUs are fully functional living spaces.
  • ADUs have more regulations and can be rented out, while guest houses may have fewer regulations and limitations on rental.
  • ADUs often have separate utilities and entrances, while guest houses may share utilities and have less delineation from the main home.
  • Local laws may restrict the size, location, and rental possibilities of ADUs, while guest houses may not be allowed to rent out at all.
  • ADUs can provide additional income, increase property value, and offer flexibility in usage, while guest houses provide privacy and potential rental income.

Table of Contents

1of 27

Comparing a Guest House and an ADU

comparing a guest house and an adu

When considering additional living spaces on a property, understanding the distinction between a guest house and an accessory dwelling unit (ADU) is crucial. Each caters to different needs and is subject to varying regulations.

Purpose and Use: A guest house is typically used for short-term stays, providing accommodation for visitors and guests without the facilities for long-term habitation. ADUs are designed as fully-functional living spaces, complete with kitchen, bathroom, and sleeping facilities, often for family members or as a rental unit.

Construction and Zoning: ADUs are built with the intention of complying with local zoning laws and occupancy regulations. They can be attached to the main house, detached, or a conversion of existing space like garages. Guest houses may face fewer regulations but often cannot be legally rented out.

Utilities and Services: ADUs often have separate utility meters and their own entrances, enhancing privacy and independence, whereas guest houses might share utilities with the main home and have less delineation from the primary living space.

Regulatory Restrictions: Local laws might impose restrictions on the size, location, and rental possibilities of ADUs, affecting the potential for generating income. Guest houses, depending on the region, may not be permissible to rent out at all.

Understanding these factors helps in making an informed decision about which structure best suits one’s needs and complies with local ordinances.

2of 27

What Is a Guest House?

what is a guest house

Characterized by its location on the property, typically separated from the main residence, a guest house serves as a secondary dwelling. Unlike an ADU, it may not necessarily be designed for full-time living, often used for hosting friends and family.

These standalone structures usually include basic living amenities such as a bedroom, bathroom, and sometimes a small kitchen or kitchenette. The size and features can vary significantly, from modest cottages to more luxurious accommodations.

Importantly, guest houses are not always legally recognized as rental units, therefore their usage might be limited according to local zoning laws.

3of 27

What Is an ADU?

what is an adu

An Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) is an additional living space on the same grounds as a primary residence. These structures can vary widely in form, including detached buildings, converted garages, or basement apartments.

Commonly known as “granny flats” or “in-law suites,” ADUs typically have their own independent facilities like a kitchen, bathroom, and sleeping area, allowing for greater privacy and autonomy than many other types of shared living spaces.

They are often used for housing family members, generating rental income, or as home offices and studios. ADUs are increasingly recognized as a means to add density and diversity to housing stock in urban and suburban neighborhoods, and many local governments have updated zoning laws to encourage their construction.

4of 27

What’s the Difference Between a Guest House and an ADU?

whats the difference between a guest house and an adu

A guest house is traditionally a separate living area on a property, designed primarily for temporary visitors or hosting guests. It may come equipped with amenities like a bedroom, bathroom, and sometimes a kitchenette, and it does not typically include full home facilities.

An ADU, or Accessory Dwelling Unit, is a secondary housing unit on a single-family residential lot, complete with its own kitchen, bathroom, and sleeping area. It’s intended for permanent residence and can be rented out as a separate unit. ADUs can be detached units, attached to the main house, or even interior ones that convert existing space within the home.

While both structures increase living space on a property, an ADU often has more formal regulations regarding construction and use, including adherence to building codes and obtaining the appropriate permits. These regulations can vary significantly from one locale to another. Guest houses, with their more informal and temporary lodging intent, may have fewer regulations, depending on local zoning laws.

5of 27

ADUs Vs. Guest House: Which Is Better?

Deciding whether to build an ADU or a guest house depends on your specific needs and local regulations. Here are some key factors to consider:

  • Permanence: ADUs are often a more permanent addition to your property, typically requiring a building permit and adherence to local zoning laws. Guest houses, depending on the jurisdiction, might be subject to fewer regulations, especially if they’re not meant for long-term occupancy.
  • Functionality: If you’re looking for a space to house a family member or a renter long-term, an ADU, with its separate living facilities, might be the better fit. Guest houses are ideal for short-term guests or as occasional use retreats.
  • Value Addition: From a real estate perspective, an ADU can significantly increase your property value. They appeal to potential homebuyers because they offer an added source of rental income or space for extended family.
  • Cost: Building an ADU might be more costly upfront due to the need to equip it with a kitchen, bathroom, and separate utilities. However, that investment could pay off if your goal is to generate rental income.
  • Zoning and Regulations: Stay informed about your local ADU and guest house regulations which can greatly affect your decision. Some areas may have restrictions on rental periods for guest houses or specific requirements that must be met for ADU construction.

By weighing these considerations against your personal needs and long-term plans, you can make an informed choice that aligns with your goals for your home and property.

6of 27

Benefits to Building an ADU

Accessibility and family proximity often top the list of reasons to build an ADU. These units can provide a separate living space for aging parents, allowing families to keep their loved ones close while maintaining privacy.

Financial benefits are also significant. Homeowners can generate passive income through renting out their ADU, which can help cover mortgage payments or fund retirement plans. Moreover, the additional dwelling can increase the overall property value.

Sustainability is an intrinsic advantage of ADUs. Their smaller size means a lower carbon footprint and less energy consumption, contributing positively to environmental conservation efforts. They also make efficient use of existing land and infrastructure, which is a smart approach to urban development.

Last but not least, ADUs offer flexibility. As a homeowner’s life evolves, so too can the purpose of the unit: a home office, an artist’s studio, or even a short-term rental space. This adaptability makes ADUs a valuable long-term investment in the utility and functionality of your property.

7of 27

The Benefits and Drawbacks of a Guest House

Having a guest house on your property presents a unique set of advantages. It offers a private space for visitors, which can enhance the comfort of both guests and homeowners. Additionally, it can serve as a potential source of rental income, depending on local regulations and market demand. Guest houses also increase property value, making them a potentially lucrative investment.

Despite these benefits, there are considerations to keep in mind. Building and maintaining a guest house can be costly, with expenses such as utilities, property taxes, and insurance likely to rise. Zoning laws may restrict the ability to construct or rent out a guest house, and neighbors might raise concerns about increased noise or traffic. Privacy can be a double-edged sword, as having tenants on your property—even in a separate structure—may affect your sense of personal space.

8of 27

ADU Laws in Select West Coast Cities

Navigating municipal regulations is crucial when considering the construction of an ADU, as they vary from city to city. Below are key legal points pertaining to some West Coast cities:

9of 27

San Francisco:

  • Permits both attached and detached ADUs in residential zones.
  • Eliminated the requirement for off-street parking.
  • Property owners can add one ADU to a single-family home and up to two in multi-family buildings.
10of 27

Los Angeles:

  • Allows detached, attached, and converted ADUs, with size limitations based on lot and existing structure sizes.
  • Newly passed regulations have streamlined the approval process, encouraging ADU development.
  • No minimum lot size, but ADUs must comply with setback and height requirements.
11of 27

Seattle:

  • Offers two options: Attached ADUs (AADUs) and Detached ADUs (DADUs).
  • Reduced the minimum lot size for ADUs and relaxed owner-occupancy rules.
  • Increased the DADU maximum size to 1,000 square feet.
12of 27

Portland:

  • Waived System Development Charges for ADUs to stimulate their creation.
  • Allows one ADU per residential lot with a size cap at 75% of the primary residence or 800 square feet, whichever is less.
  • No longer requires the property owner to live on-site.

These highlights serve as a starting guide and it’s important to review the most recent regulations with your local planning department.

13of 27

San Francisco

In San Francisco, the ADU program allows property owners to add a new unit or legalize an existing unit in the interior space of an eligible residential building. This initiative supports the city’s goal to expand housing availability and affordability.

San Francisco’s specific regulations outline that:

  • The property must be zoned for residential use.
  • ADUs are permissible within the existing envelope of a building, including basements and garages.
  • For buildings with four or fewer existing units, there’s no limit to the number of ADUs that can be added, as long as space allows.
  • Owner-occupancy requirements for ADUs were suspended until 2025, making it easier for non-resident owners to add ADUs.

These rules endeavor to harness underutilized spaces within the city’s urban fabric, fostering a more diverse housing stock. However, it’s crucial for property owners to consult with the San Francisco Planning Department for the most current policies and specific stipulations, as regulations can evolve.

14of 27

Los Angeles

In Los Angeles, the regulations surrounding ADUs have evolved to support the city’s growing need for housing. Homeowners in Los Angeles can convert garages, build new standalone structures, or create attached ADUs. Key points to consider include:

  • Eligibility: Most single-family properties are eligible for ADU development, provided they meet zoning requirements.
  • Size Limits: ADUs can be up to 1,200 square feet, depending on the size of the primary residence and lot.
  • Parking: No additional parking is required for ADUs created within existing structures or located within half a mile of public transit.
  • Renting: Both ADUs and guest houses can be rented out in Los Angeles; however, the property owner must dwell in one of the units on the property.
  • Guest House Restrictions: Guest houses are not intended for permanent rental and typically lack a full kitchen, limiting their use compared to ADUs.
  • Permit Process: Los Angeles has streamlined the permitting process with an online portal and pre-approved plans to encourage ADU development.

These points offer a glimpse into the specific requirements and advantages for homeowners considering an ADU or guest house in Los Angeles, reflecting the city’s push towards increasing accessible and affordable housing options.

15of 27

Seattle

Seattle’s mild climate and booming tech sector have contributed to a high demand for housing. In response, the city has made efforts to streamline the process for homeowners to add ADUs. Here are some key points regarding Seattle’s stance on ADUs:

  • Zoning Regulation Changes: Seattle has eased zoning regulations in residential areas, allowing both attached and detached ADUs on the same lot as a single-family home.
  • Owner-Occupancy Requirements: Previously, homeowners were required to live on the property to rent out ADUs. This restriction has been lifted, widening the potential for rental opportunities.
  • Size and Height: Detached ADUs can be up to 1000 square feet, and the maximum height allowed is between 15 to 22 feet, depending on the lot size and configuration.
  • Design Options: The city encourages design flexibility, so long as the ADU fits within the character of the neighborhood.
  • Renting Regulations: Short-term rental regulations apply differently to ADUs compared to guest houses, with ADUs often having less stringent rules, making them preferable for long-term rental strategies.

These points help homeowners become informed about the potential for ADUs on their property in Seattle, providing options to address the city’s housing needs while creating an opportunity for income or additional living space.

16of 27

Portland

Portland has embraced ADUs as a solution to its housing needs. The city has taken steps to ease zoning laws, allowing homeowners to build both interior and detached ADUs on their properties.

Some highlights of Portland’s regulations include:

  • Elimination of off-street parking requirements for ADUs to reduce construction costs.
  • Allowing two ADUs on a single lot: one interior and one detached.
  • Permitting ADUs to be built on lots with both single-family homes and duplexes.
  • Homeowners can live in either the primary or accessory unit.
  • ADUs must maintain a design in harmony with the existing residence to preserve neighborhood character.

Portland’s proactive approach aims to increase affordable housing options while maintaining the fabric of its communities. Homeowners considering an ADU should check for the most current regulations with the city to ensure compliance.

17of 27

Flexible Space Is Key to Rental ADUs and Guest House ADUs

Maximizing the usefulness of an area within your home is essential, whether you opt for an ADU or a guest house. With thoughtful design, these spaces can be transformed to serve multiple purposes:

  • Convertible Furnishings: Invest in furniture that can easily be converted, such as Murphy beds or futons. This allows the room to act as a living space during the day and a bedroom at night.
  • Built-in Storage: Utilizing built-in storage solutions can free up floor space, making the room feel larger and more versatile.
  • Outdoor Integration: Incorporate large doors or windows that open to outdoor living spaces. This expands the usable area and blurs the line between indoor and outdoor environments.
  • Multipurpose Rooms: Design rooms that can be utilized for various functions, such as a space that can act as a home office, a workout room, or a hobby area depending on the needs of the occupants.

These strategies enable your ADU or guest house to adapt to changing circumstances and needs, enhancing its long-term rental appeal or utility for guests.

18of 27

Reasons to Build a Granny Flat for an Elderly Loved One

Granny flats, a popular type of ADU, offer an excellent housing solution for elderly loved ones. Their proximity to the main residence fosters family support while maintaining independence. This arrangement can:

  • Enhance Comfort: Tailored to meet specific needs, granny flats can incorporate accessibility features, fostering a safe environment.
  • Increase Social Interaction: Close to family, elderly members can engage more frequently in social activities, combatting loneliness.
  • Promote Independence: With a separate space, seniors enjoy their independence with the security of knowing help is nearby if needed.
  • Cost-Effective: Compared to senior homes, granny flats are often a more affordable option, without sacrificing quality care or comfort.
  • Offer Peace of Mind: Family members gain peace of mind knowing their loved ones are just steps away.
  • Property Value: Well-designed flats can add value to your property, a benefit if future resale is considered.
  • Flexibility for Future Use: Once no longer needed for elder care, the space can serve as a guest house, rental unit, or home office.

By considering these points, a granny flat might just be the ideal compromise between autonomy and closeness for your elderly family members.

19of 27

Affordable Housing Crunch in the Bay Area: The Solution May Be in Your Backyard

In the context of the Bay Area’s steep housing prices, homeowners are considering creative ways to tackle affordability issues. Enter accessory dwelling units (ADUs), seen as a promising solution. By converting garages or basements, or erecting a small standalone unit on existing property, ADUs expand housing options without the need for new land.

Here’s how ADUs help ease the affordable housing crunch:

  • Lower Cost: ADUs typically cost less to build per square foot than a standard-sized home, making them a more affordable addition to the housing market.
  • Rental Income: For homeowners, ADUs offer a source of rental income, which can help with mortgage payments or as a means of supplemental income.
  • Community Impact: Integrating smaller, more affordable units into established neighborhoods helps maintain community diversity, allowing for a mix of families, singles, and seniors.
  • Sustainability: Small-scale, high-density living options like ADUs encourage more efficient use of resources and lower carbon footprints compared to larger, single-family homes.
  • Multigenerational Living: ADUs provide the perfect setup for families looking to keep relatives close (but not too close), reinforcing family bonds while offering independence.
  • Reduced Urban Sprawl: Encouraging more ADUs reduces the need to build on undeveloped land, preserving green spaces and curbing the spread of urban sprawl.
  • Utilization of Existing Infrastructure: ADUs make use of existing infrastructure such as roads, sewer systems, and power lines, which is often more cost-effective than extending services to new developments.
20of 27

Pros & Cons of a Guest House

Guest houses offer a unique combination of privacy and proximity, allowing homeowners the opportunity to host visitors or generate rental income while maintaining a separate space. They typically come with their own set of amenities and utilities, mirroring the main residence in comfort and design. However, there are several considerations to bear in mind.

21of 27

Advantages:

  • Privacy: Guests or tenants have their own space, giving both parties more privacy.
  • Potential Income: Renting out the guest house can provide an additional source of income.
  • Property Value: A well-constructed guest house may increase the overall value of your property.
  • Versatility: Guest houses can be used for a multitude of purposes, from a home office to a space for long-term guests or aging family members.
22of 27

Challenges:

  • Cost: Building and maintaining a guest house is often more expensive than an ADU due to separate utility systems and amenities.
  • Zoning Regulations: There may be stricter zoning laws or building codes to contend with, which can complicate construction.
  • Space Requirements: Guest houses usually require more land, limiting their feasibility for smaller properties.
  • Privacy for Homeowner: While guests enjoy privacy, homeowners may find their own privacy reduced with tenants living on their property.
23of 27

Pros & Cons of an ADU

Pros of an ADU:

  • Additional Income: Renting out an ADU can provide homeowners with a steady source of additional income.
  • Increased Property Value: ADUs can increase the overall value of the property.
  • Flexibility: ADUs can serve multiple purposes over time, from housing family members to serving as a home office.
  • Affordable Housing Option: They offer a more affordable housing option for renters in high-cost areas.
  • Sustainability: Building an ADU is often more sustainable than new, single-family homes due to their smaller size and efficient use of land.

Cons of an ADU:

  • Initial Costs: The upfront costs of construction can be significant.
  • Zoning and Regulation: Navigating local zoning laws and building codes can be complex and time-consuming.
  • Limited Space: ADUs are smaller in size, which may limit rental appeal or functionality for some families.
  • Potential for Conflict: Close proximity to tenants can lead to conflicts if not managed properly.
  • Parking and Privacy: Adding a rental unit can lead to issues with parking and reduced privacy for some homeowners.
24of 27

Laws Regarding ADUs and Guest Houses

Understanding local regulations is crucial when considering an accessory dwelling unit (ADU) or guest house. Below are key points that highlight important legislative aspects:

Zoning: Verify your property is zoned for an ADU or guest house. Zoning laws dictate land use and will determine if you can build.

Permits: You will need building permits for construction. The process can vary greatly between municipalities, so check local requirements.

Size restrictions: ADUs typically have limits on square footage. These range depending on the city but are often a percentage of the primary residence’s size.

Occupancy rules: Some areas may restrict use to family members or impose rental restrictions on ADUs or guest houses.

Utilities and Accessibility: There may be regulations regarding separate utilities for ADUs and guest houses, and accessibility might be influenced by the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).

Parking: Additional off-street parking may be required, especially if the ADU will be used for rental purposes.

Design and Aesthetics: ADUs and guest houses often need to match the existing home’s aesthetic and comply with community standards.

These points are a starting place for understanding legal requirements. Always consult with your local planning department for the most current and applicable regulations.

25of 27

Los Angeles ADU and Guest House Laws

In Los Angeles, regulations for ADUs and guest houses have evolved to address housing shortages, providing property owners with clear guidelines for development. Here’s a snapshot of the current laws:

1. ADU Size Limits: ADUs can be up to 1,200 square feet, depending on the size and zoning of the primary residence.

2. Parking Requirements: Generally, no additional parking is required for an ADU if it’s within half a mile of public transit.

3. Conversion of Existing Structures: Garages, sheds, and existing living spaces may be converted into ADUs, bypassing some new construction requirements.

4. Owner-Occupancy: The owner-occupancy mandate, requiring property owners to live on-site, has been suspended until 2025 for new ADUs.

5. Guest House Restrictions: Unlike ADUs, guest houses typically cannot have full kitchens and are not meant to be rented out.

These points highlight the city’s efforts to encourage ADU construction as a means to increase affordable housing options while still maintaining distinct rules for traditional guest houses.

26of 27

San Francisco ADU and Guest House Laws

San Francisco’s approach to Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) aims to address housing shortages while optimizing existing space. Here are some key points on local ADU law:

  • Zoning: Most residential properties can add one ADU regardless of zoning, with possibilities for two on larger lots.
  • Size and design: ADUs can be up to 800 square feet or 75% the size of the primary unit. Design must complement existing structures.
  • Rent: ADUs can be rented – a boon for homeowners seeking extra income. Short-term rentals, however, are generally prohibited.
  • Conversion of space: Conversion of existing space into an ADU is permitted, including garages and basements.
  • Permitting process: Streamlined yet thorough, aiming to ensure safety and compliance while facilitating the creation of new living spaces.

Guest houses, not intended for rent and often without full kitchens, typically face fewer restrictions but must comply with local building codes. It’s essential to consult the San Francisco Planning Department for the most current regulations and processes.

27of 27

FAQ

What is the difference between a Casita and an ADU?

A casita and an ADU (Accessory Dwelling Unit) differ in that while all casitas are ADUs, not all ADUs are casitas, primarily due to size limitations, with casitas traditionally being up to 800 square feet and ADUs being as large as 1,200 square feet.

What makes something a guest house?

A guest house is an accessory building, typically on the same site as a main dwelling unit, that houses sleeping units without kitchen facilities for occasional, non-paying visitors, and usually has a floor area of 640 square feet or less.

What is the difference between a guest quarter and an ADU?

The primary difference between a guest quarter and an Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) is that an ADU is designed for everyday living and accessibility, providing affordable housing, whereas a guest quarter is not typically intended for long-term living.

What is the difference between an ADU and a room addition?

An ADU, or Accessory Dwelling Unit, is a distinct living space with its own entrance, kitchen, and bathroom, that can be detached or attached to a home, while a room addition is simply an expansion of the existing house that doesn’t come with separate functional facilities.

How does the permitting process differ for an ADU versus a guest house?

The main distinguishing factor in the permitting process for an ADU (Accessory Dwelling Unit) versus a guest house is that an ADU, which often includes a full kitchen and bathroom, generally requires more extensive permits related to plumbing and electrical systems, whereas a guest house usually requires fewer, simpler permits due to its limited amenities.

What are the environmental benefits of constructing an ADU compared to a traditional guest house?

Constructing an ADU (Accessory Dwelling Unit) typically involves less environmental impact than a traditional guest house as it requires fewer materials and energy for construction, and promotes efficient land use due to its smaller size.

How does the architectural design of an ADU differ from that of a standard room addition?

An accessory dwelling unit (ADU) is architecturally designed as a standalone living space with its own kitchen and bathroom facilities, distinct from the main house, whereas a standard room addition is typically integrated into the existing structure as an expansion of the current living space.

Related reading:

Read more

Read more

Read more

Read more

Read more

Read more