Jadu vs ADU: Understanding The Difference In Accessory Dwelling Units

Last updated on April 10, 2024

Understanding the differences between JADU (Junior Accessory Dwelling Units) and ADU (Accessory Dwelling Units) is essential for homeowners considering adding a secondary dwelling on their property.

Key takeaways:

JADUs are smaller than ADUs, usually limited to 500 square feet.
JADUs are often converted from existing spaces, while ADUs can be new structures.
ADUs have independent living facilities, while JADUs may share amenities with the main home.
JADUs may have a shared interior connection with the main home.
ADUs may have more flexibility for rental income compared to JADUs.

1of 4

What Is a JADU?

Junior Accessory Dwelling Units (JADUs) are a type of secondary housing unit with a unique twist. Originally birthed from California’s housing legislation, a JADU is typically no larger than 500 square feet and is created within existing residential spaces—think of areas like converted garages or attached workshops. They must provide independent living facilities for sleeping, eating, cooking, and sanitation on the same parcel as the single-family dwelling is situated.

What sets JADUs apart is that they often incorporate shared facilities with the primary unit, such as a bathroom or an entryway. An interior connection between the JADU and the main dwelling must exist, but it can also have a separate entrance. Also, owner-occupancy in either the primary dwelling or the JADU itself is a common requirement, ensuring that these spaces contribute to the local housing stock without fully transforming neighborhoods into rental areas. Energetically embracing both affordability and efficient use of space, JADUs serve as a creative solution in densely populated regions where housing is at a premium.

2of 4

Key Differences Between an ADU and JADU

Understanding the distinctions between an Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) and a Junior Accessory Dwelling Unit (JADU) is crucial for homeowners considering an expansion of their living space. Here are the key differences:

Size:
A JADU is typically smaller than an ADU, limited in most cases to a maximum of 500 square feet, while ADUs can be larger, with size limitations varying based on local regulations.

Conversion:
JADUs are commonly created by converting a portion of the existing primary residence, such as a bedroom or attached garage. ADUs, on the other hand, can be new standalone structures or conversions that often include detached garages or basement conversions.

Facilities:
ADUs are required to have complete independent living facilities for sleeping, cooking, and sanitation. In contrast, JADUs may share sanitation facilities with the primary residence and are often not required to have a full kitchen, allowing for kitchenette-style setups.

Entrance:
Both ADUs and JADUs must have separate entrances from the main home, but JADUs are unique in that they may share an interior connection with the primary residence, which can be locked off.

Owner Occupancy:
Regulations for JADUs may require the property owner to live in either the primary residence or the JADU. ADUs, depending on the jurisdiction, often have no such requirement, allowing homeowners more flexibility in terms of renting out either space.

Permits and Regulations:
While permitting requirements vary by location, JADUs can sometimes benefit from a simplified permit process and reduced fees compared to ADUs due to their smaller size and integration with the existing structure.

Rental Possibilities:
Both ADUs and JADUs can add rental income potential, but the smaller size and shared amenities of a JADU might attract a different type of renter, such as a single individual, compared to the larger and more private ADU.

Understanding these nuances aids in making an informed decision about which type of additional dwelling unit is optimal for a homeowner’s specific circumstances and goals.

3of 4

JADU Vs. ADU – Which One Is Right for You?

Choosing between a Junior Accessory Dwelling Unit (JADU) and an Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) hinges on evaluating personal needs, property specifications, and financial considerations. If space on your property is limited, a JADU, typically no larger than 500 square feet, might be an ideal solution. This type of unit facilitates the utilization of existing space within your home, such as converting a bedroom or attached garage into a separate living area.

For homeowners seeking a more private and spacious option, an ADU, which can be built as a detached unit, a conversion of existing space, or an addition to your home, offers a flexible range of sizes up to 1,200 square feet or more in some jurisdictions. ADUs are standalone structures with dedicated entrance, kitchen, and bathroom facilities, which can accommodate tenants seeking full living units or serve as an independent area for family members.

Budget considerations are also crucial. JADUs are generally more cost-effective, taking advantage of existing structures and systems in your home. On the other hand, ADUs might require a higher initial investment, but they potentially offer higher rental income due to their larger size and independence from the primary dwelling.

When assessing local regulations, ensure that your choice aligns with zoning laws and permitting processes. Some areas may have restrictions on either JADUs or ADUs or may offer incentives for developing one type of unit over the other.

Lastly, consider your long-term objectives. If maximizing rental income or increasing property value is the top priority, an ADU could be the more lucrative option. Conversely, if you’re looking for a solution that enhances the living space within the footprint of your existing home, a JADU might be the perfect avenue to explore.

4of 4

Can I Have an ADU and JADU in California?

Certainly, California homeowners have the unique opportunity to maximize their property’s potential by adding both an Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) and a Junior Accessory Dwelling Unit (JADU). This stems from the state’s ongoing efforts to address the housing shortage by offering flexible options.

Here are a few key points to keep in mind:

State legislation in California allows a single-family home to construct one ADU and one JADU. This approach can significantly enhance the value and functionality of your property.
A JADU is typically smaller in size, generally limited to 500 square feet, and must be contained within the existing walls of your home. It can share the main home’s bathroom or include a small kitchenette for efficiency.
An ADU, on the other hand, is a fully independent unit that can be either attached or detached from the main dwelling. It needs to provide complete living facilities, including a kitchen, bathroom, and sleeping area.
Building both types of units could be an exceptional strategy for homeowners looking to generate rental income or comfortably accommodate family members while still ensuring everyone’s privacy.

It’s essential to check with your local city or county for specific regulations, as they may have additional requirements or restrictions beyond the statewide provisions.