Can You Recycle Ice Cream Cartons: An Informative Guide on Proper Disposal Methods

Last updated on April 8, 2024

Discover a comprehensive guide instructing how to properly recycle ice cream cartons, addressing a common question among consumers.Ice cream cartons, an item frequently found in many households, can sometimes be a source of confusion when it comes to recycling. Are these cartons recyclable, or do they belong in the trash? The answer lies in the very composition of the cartons themselves.Ice cream cartons are often made of paperboard and have an inner lining of polyethylene, a type of plastic. This combination makes them sturdy and able to handle the cold temperature of the freezer while providing a hygienic container for food. A common assumption is that paper-based products like ice cream cartons can be tossed into curbside recycling bins problem-free. However, this is not the case.While the paperboard part of the carton is recyclable, the polyethylene inner lining complicates things. This plastic lining is hard to separate from the paperboard and most recycling facilities lack the equipment needed to process this mixture of materials.That said, some facilities do have the required technology, and several ice cream producers are switching to cartons coated with a recyclable plastic. This change enables these containers to be recycled under specific conditions. Therefore, it’s imperative to check with your local recycling program before recycling ice cream cartons.If the cartons are not accepted in your local program, consider reusing them instead of tossing them in the trash. These cartons can serve a vast range of purposes, from storing small items to starting seeds for your garden, reducing the demand for new materials.In conclusion, the recyclability of ice cream cartons is not black and white and largely depends on your local recycling rules and the type of cartons your ice cream comes in. While it might take a little bit of homework, finding a planet-friendly solution for disposing of these cartons is entirely achievable.

Key takeaways:

  • Ice cream cartons are often made of paperboard with a plastic lining.
  • The plastic lining makes them difficult to recycle in many facilities.
  • Some facilities have technology to recycle these cartons.
  • Check with your local recycling program to see if they accept ice cream cartons.
  • If not recyclable, consider reusing the cartons for storage or as planters.
1of 6

Materials Used in Ice Cream Cartons

Ice cream cartons typically consist of a paperboard shell, which provides the primary structure. However, the key to their durability in the freezer is a thin interior coating, often made of plastic or a plastic-aluminum combination, to prevent the paperboard from becoming soggy due to the moisture in ice cream. This lining is essential for preserving the quality and texture of the ice cream but complicates the recycling process. Some brands also use a wax coating, although this is less common than the polyethylene plastic coatings employed widely across the industry due to cost and effectiveness.

Additionally, cartons may feature a glossy exterior finish, which not only attracts consumers with vibrant graphics but also acts as a moisture barrier. The inks and adhesives used for labeling and sealing the packaging have improved over time to withstand low temperatures and condensation, yet they too play a part in the recyclability of these containers. All these materials must be taken into account when recycling facilities process ice cream cartons.

2of 6

Are Paper Ice Cream Cartons Recyclable?

When it comes to the recyclability of paper ice cream cartons, things get a bit complicated. Most of these cartons are coated with a thin layer of polyethylene (plastic) to prevent sogginess and freezer burn. This coating is excellent for preserving your sweet treat but poses a problem for recycling facilities.

The hybrid materials—paper mixed with plastic—require a specialized process to separate and recycle. Many local facilities lack the technology to do so, meaning these cartons often end up in landfills instead of being repurposed.

However, it isn’t all doom and gloom. An increase in consumer demand for sustainable packaging has led some communities to invest in the necessary equipment to properly recycle these materials. Hence, the key step before tossing your container in the recycling bin is to check with your local waste management policies. Some communities have specific guidelines or collection programs for these hybrid containers, while others might direct you to dispose of them with your general waste.

Remember, proper recycling etiquette not only involves knowing what can be recycled, but also understanding local recycling capabilities and guidelines. Before disposing of your ice cream carton, a quick search or phone call can ensure you’re enhancing your environmental impact, not hindering it.

3of 6

Challenges With Recycling Ice Cream Cartons

Recycling ice cream cartons isn’t as straightforward as tossing them into the blue bin. The primary obstacle is the polyethylene coating inside the carton, which acts as a moisture barrier to prevent sogginess but complicates the recycling process. This coating must be separated from the paper, requiring specialized facilities that not all recycling centers possess.

Additionally, remnants of ice cream left in the container can contaminate other recyclables if not properly cleaned, adding another layer of complexity. Moreover, the mixed material composition of these cartons often places them in a gray area of recyclability, where the specific recycling guidelines vary greatly from one municipality to another.

Lastly, the small size and light weight of ice cream cartons can pose sorting challenges in single-stream recycling systems, leading to potential rejection at the recovery facility. Overall, these challenges necessitate a careful approach and often the need for consumers to take extra steps to ensure their ice cream cartons are disposed of responsibly.

4of 6

A City-by-City Solution for Ice Cream Carton Recycling

Recycling practices vary significantly from one municipality to another, reflecting the localized approach to dealing with ice cream cartons. This mosaic of regulations is shaped by the capabilities and contracts of local recycling facilities. For example, a city with access to a recycling plant equipped to separate paper from plastic linings might accept these cartons in their curbside program. In contrast, another city might exclude them due to the absence of such technology.

Cities that do recycle these cartons generally have specific instructions to ensure proper processing. For instance, residents may be asked to rinse and dry the cartons before disposal to reduce contamination. Some cities may also encourage flattening the cartons to save space in recycling bins.

The best course of action is to check with local waste management authorities. Many provide detailed guidelines online or through informative flyers, specifying what can and cannot be included in the recycling stream. Engaging with community education programs or local environmental groups can also provide clarity and even influence improvements in local recycling capabilities.

5of 6

Ways to Reuse Ice Cream Cartons

Turning your empty ice cream cartons into planters is a delightful way to give them a second life. The size makes them perfect for starting seeds or growing small herbs. Just poke a few drainage holes in the bottom, fill with potting soil, and you’re ready to go green.

For those who love to organize, these sturdy containers can be transformed into storage solutions. They can easily hold craft supplies, small toys, or even be used in the garage for sorting screws and nails. The waterproof lining is an added bonus for items that might leak or ooze.

If you’re into DIY, consider covering the cartons with fabric or wrapping paper to create customized gift boxes. Your friends and family will appreciate the effort and the unique packaging.

For the artists and educators, ice cream cartons can be cut and unfolded to provide a blank canvas. They can then be decorated and used as signs or educational materials because of their durability and the ease with which they can be mounted or displayed.

If you’re an avid bird lover, transform an old ice cream carton into a bird feeder. A few holes, some string for hanging, and a stick glued to the bottom as a perch, and voilà – you’ve created a welcome spot for feathered friends.

Lastly, with environmental consciousness in mind, these cartons can become handy compost bins for kitchen scraps. Transfer the biodegradable waste to your main compost pile as needed without the need for plastic bags.

6of 6


Can you recycle Ben and Jerry’s cartons?

While the paperboard packaging of many Ben and Jerry’s products is broadly recyclable, containers from certain flavors that incorporate plastic or mixed materials, like their pint-sized tubs, may not be.

Are ice cream containers recyclable in NYC?

In NYC, ice cream containers can be recycled, provided they are made of the appropriate kind of plastic and thoroughly cleaned to prevent contamination of other recyclable items.

Are milk cartons actually recyclable?

Yes, all types of milk cartons are potentially recyclable, but their recyclability largely hinges on the capabilities of local recycling facilities.

Are milk cartons recyclable in NYC?

Yes, in New York City, milk cartons are recyclable, keeping in mind that they should not be recycled with mixed paper due to their plastic film lining.

What type of recycling process is suitable for yogurt containers?

Yogurt containers, usually made from plastic type 5 (polypropylene), are best recycled through curbside recycling programs that accept this type of plastic.

Are paper-based ice cream tubs recyclable in San Francisco?

Yes, paper-based ice cream tubs are recyclable in San Francisco.

Do companies offer recyclable packaging options for frozen desserts?

Yes, some companies do offer recyclable packaging options for frozen desserts.

Related reading:

Read more

Read more

Read more

Read more

Read more

Read more

Table of Contents